Hefley Award Winners
| 1974: Tim Sutton | 1999: | 2024: Sammy Geiger |
| 1975: Troy Apple & Scott Brown | 2000: | |
| 1976: Greg Richards | 2001: | |
| 1977: Kurt Williams | 2002: | |
| 1978: Robby Krause | 2003: | |
| 1979: Chuck Roembke | 2004: | |
| 1980: Joe Ratliff | 2005: | |
| 1981: Dana Selke | 2006: | |
| 1982: Seth Northern | 2007: | |
| 1983: | 2008: | |
| 1984: | 2009: | |
| 1985: | 2010: | |
| 1986: | 2011: | |
| 1987: | 2012: Sam Hohlt | |
| 1988: | 2013: | |
| 1989: | 2014:Ty Hohlt | |
| 1990: | 2015:Gabe Boyd | |
| 1991: | 2016: Eli Hohlt | |
| 1992: Jeremy Messer | 2017: Caden McConnell, Tyler Cherry & William Spellman
| |
| 1993: Rob Shirley | 2018: TJ Williams | |
| 1994: Matt Kaler | 2019: Gannon Grant | |
| 1995: | 2020: Grady Grant | |
| 1996: Bobby Orr | 2021: Isaac Long | |
| 1997: Kevin Shaw | 2022: Emmitt Anderson | |
| 1998: | 2023: Luke Cherry | |